Sidewalk Slip and Fall Lawyer in Manhattan: Claims Against Property Owners and the City

When you slip or trip on a Manhattan sidewalk, the owner of the property next to that sidewalk is responsible in most cases. NYC Administrative Code § 7-210 requires property owners to keep their sidewalks reasonably safe. The City of New York stays responsible for curbs, tree wells, and sidewalks in front of owner-occupied one-, two-, and three-family homes.

Who owns the spot where you fell changes everything about your claim. A case against a private owner gives you three years to file. A case against the City requires a Notice of Claim within 90 days. Michael Gunzburg, P.C. has more than 39 years of New York City trial experience, including a $750,000 trial settlement for a woman injured in a hole in a public sidewalk. The attorney or an investigator for the firm goes to the scene to document the defect before anyone patches it. Michael Gunzburg is also a Certified Public Accountant, so your lost earnings and future losses are calculated with a CPA's precision. Call (212) 725-8500 for a free consultation.

Last Updated: November 2026. Sidewalk liability rules and filing deadlines reflect New York City and New York State law as of this date.

What Our Clients Say

Who Needs a Sidewalk Slip and Fall Lawyer in Manhattan?

You need a sidewalk slip and fall lawyer if you fell on a broken, raised, or hazardous sidewalk in Manhattan and got hurt. That includes trips over uneven slabs, falls into holes or tree wells, and stumbles at subway grates or utility covers. It also includes falls under scaffolding and falls on City property like plazas, park paths, and the walkways outside public buildings. Most people have no idea who is legally responsible for the exact spot where they fell. Sorting that out is the first job of the firm's Manhattan slip and fall practice, whether you fell in the Financial District, Midtown, or Harlem. Falls on ice and snow have their own rules, covered on the Manhattan ice and snow slip and fall page.

Common Sidewalk Fall Situations in Manhattan

Tripping on a Slab Lifted by Tree Roots

Tree roots lift sidewalk slabs on the brownstone blocks of the Upper West Side and Greenwich Village. The building owner is usually responsible for the raised slab. If you fell inside the tree well itself, though, the claim runs against the City.

Falling at a Subway Grate or Utility Cover

Subway grates, manhole covers, and utility plates line Midtown avenues and the streets around Grand Central and Penn Station. The owner of that hardware is responsible for it and for the 12 inches of sidewalk around it. That owner may be the MTA, Con Edison, or a telecom company, not the building owner. Read more about suing over subway-related injuries.

Falling Under Scaffolding or a Sidewalk Shed

Sidewalk sheds cover long stretches of Midtown and the Financial District during facade work. Loose plywood, debris, poor lighting, and uneven temporary walkways cause falls here. The contractor and the building owner can both be responsible.

Stepping on a Broken or Open Cellar Door

Steel cellar doors set into the sidewalk are common in front of shops in SoHo, Chinatown, and the Lower East Side. A warped, slick, or unexpectedly open door can drop you onto the metal or into the opening below. The property owner is responsible, and a business that uses the doors can share responsibility in some cases.

Tripping at a Corner or Curb

Corner properties must maintain the sidewalk quadrant at the intersection, which is where crowds bunch up waiting to cross. The curb itself is different. Courts treat the curb as part of the street, which usually puts it on the City.

Falling Into a Hole Near Construction or a Utility Cut

Contractors and utility crews open Manhattan sidewalks constantly and don't always restore them properly. A sunken patch or an unfilled cut can catch your foot. The company that did the work can be responsible, along with the property owner.

Falling on City Property

Falls happen on public plazas, park paths, and the walkways outside public schools and government buildings. These claims run against the City or a public agency. That means the 90-day Notice of Claim deadline applies from day one.

Who Is Liable for a Sidewalk Slip and Fall in Manhattan?

Five parties can be liable for a Manhattan sidewalk fall: the property owner next to the sidewalk, the City of New York, the owner of a grate or utility cover, a contractor working on the sidewalk, and a business that uses the sidewalk for its own purposes. Many falls involve more than one of them. Naming the right ones early protects your claim.

The Property Owner Next to the Sidewalk

The owner of the building that borders the sidewalk is responsible for keeping it reasonably safe under Administrative Code § 7-210. That law took effect in 2003 and shifted sidewalk liability from the City to property owners. The duty is nondelegable. A lease that makes a tenant handle the sidewalk doesn't take the owner off the hook to you. To win, you need to show the owner created the defect or knew, or should have known, about it and failed to fix it. This is a form of premises liability, and it covers office towers, co-ops, condos, and commercial buildings across Manhattan.

The City of New York

The City remains responsible for several parts of the sidewalk system. These include sidewalks in front of one-, two-, and three-family homes that are owner-occupied and used only as residences, tree wells, curbs, and City-owned property such as plazas, park paths, and the walkways outside City buildings. Claims against the City carry two hurdles. First, you must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days. Second, under the City's prior written notice law (Administrative Code § 7-201(c)(2)), the City generally must have received written notice of the specific defect at least 15 days before your fall. That rule has exceptions, including defects the City itself created.

Owners of Grates, Manhole Covers, and Utility Plates

The owner of a sidewalk grate, manhole cover, or utility plate is responsible for that hardware and the 12 inches of sidewalk surrounding it under 34 RCNY § 2-07. In Manhattan, that owner is often New York City Transit (part of the MTA) for subway grates, Con Edison for utility covers, or a telecom company. Claims against the MTA and other public authorities also require a Notice of Claim on a short deadline.

Contractors and Permit Holders

A contractor that opened the sidewalk, built a sidewalk shed, or did a poor repair can be liable for the hazard it left behind. Contractors work under permits from the NYC Department of Transportation or the Department of Buildings, and those permits identify who did the work and when. Falls under sidewalk sheds often overlap with scaffolding accident claims.

Businesses That Use the Sidewalk

A business that uses part of the sidewalk for its own benefit, such as cellar doors for deliveries, can share responsibility for that area under the "special use" rule. A commercial tenant isn't liable to you just because it rents the building.

Common Sidewalk Defects That Cause Falls in Manhattan

Raised slabs and holes cause most Manhattan sidewalk falls, and NYC law spells out when a defect is serious enough that the owner must repair it.

Raised or Uneven Sidewalk Slabs

A raised slab is a section of sidewalk sitting higher than the one next to it. Administrative Code § 19-152 treats a height difference of one-half inch or more between adjacent slabs as a trip hazard the owner must repair. Tree roots, freeze-thaw cycles, and settling soil cause most of these lifts.

Holes, Cracks, and Missing Concrete

Holes and broken concrete catch a foot and twist an ankle in a split second. The same code section treats a surface defect at least one inch across in every direction and one-half inch deep as a substantial defect. Missing slabs count too.

Raised Grates and Protruding Hardware

A grate or cover that sits above or below the surrounding concrete is a classic trip hazard. City rules require street hardware to sit flush with the surface around it. These falls usually point to the hardware owner rather than the building owner.

How Big Does a Sidewalk Defect Have to Be in New York?

New York has no minimum size a sidewalk defect must reach before you can sue. New York's highest court, the Court of Appeals, has rejected a fixed-inch rule. Courts look at the whole picture: the defect's width, depth, and shape, plus the lighting, foot traffic, and weather when you fell. A shallow defect can still support a claim if it was hidden or sat where crowds kept you from seeing it, such as a busy Midtown corner at rush hour. Owners often argue a defect was "trivial," meaning too small to matter. Measurements and photos taken soon after your fall are the best answer to that argument.

Why Hiring a Manhattan Sidewalk Slip and Fall Lawyer Matters

The biggest risks in a sidewalk case are suing the wrong party and missing the City's 90-day notice deadline, and either mistake can end your claim before it starts. The liability rules above overlap, and owners, the City, and utility companies routinely point at each other. A lawyer checks property ownership records, permit histories, and whether the City had written notice of the defect before the 15-day cutoff. The defect matters just as much, because owners often repair it soon after a fall. Michael Gunzburg, P.C. visited the scene of Jeffrey's West Village trip and fall the morning after being hired. The firm then won a court ruling that the step violated the New York City Building Code, and the case settled for $1.7 million at mediation. Falls without witnesses can still succeed, as the firm explains in what happens if no one saw your slip and fall.

New York's Comparative Negligence Law: What If You Weren't Watching Your Step?

New York follows pure comparative negligence under CPLR § 1411, so you can recover damages even if you were partly at fault for your fall. Your award goes down by your share of the blame. If you're found 30% at fault, you still recover 70%. Owners often argue you should have seen the defect. In New York, an open and obvious hazard doesn't erase the owner's duty to keep the sidewalk safe. At most, it can reduce your share. If you were told you were "partly to blame," call (212) 725-8500 before you accept that as the final word.

Compensation Available After a Manhattan Sidewalk Fall

A successful sidewalk claim pays for your financial losses and for the pain the injury caused. Sidewalk falls often cause broken wrists, hip and ankle fractures, knee injuries, and head injuries, which can mean surgery and months away from work.

Economic Damages

Economic damages cover losses with a dollar figure: medical bills, physical therapy, future treatment, lost wages, and lost earning capacity if you can't return to your job. Michael Gunzburg is a Certified Public Accountant as well as an attorney. That background shapes how the firm builds the lost-earnings side of a claim, especially for clients facing reduced hours, a career change, or early retirement.

Non-Economic Damages

Non-economic damages compensate you for pain, suffering, loss of mobility, and the activities your injury took away. These often make up the largest part of a sidewalk claim, but they're also the hardest to value without medical records and testimony. Note that punitive damages aren't available against the City of New York. See what Manhattan slip and fall claims are worth for a deeper look at settlement values.

Critical Deadlines for Manhattan Sidewalk Fall Claims

The 90-day Notice of Claim is the most important deadline in a sidewalk case against the City or a public authority, and missing it can end your claim. Which deadlines apply depends on who is responsible for the spot where you fell.

Deadline

Applies to

Rule

90 days

City, MTA, other public entities

File a Notice of Claim (GML § 50-e)

30 days after notice

City claims

Earliest date you can sue, after any 50-h hearing

1 year and 90 days

City, MTA, other public entities

File the lawsuit (GML § 50-i)

3 years

Private property owners and contractors

File the lawsuit (CPLR § 214)

90 Days: Notice of Claim Against the City

You must serve a Notice of Claim on the NYC Comptroller's Office within 90 days of your fall. The notice describes when, where, and how you were hurt, and it must pinpoint the defect's location. The Comptroller accepts notices online, in person, or by certified mail, as explained on the Comptroller's personal injury claim page. Before you can sue, the City can require a 50-h hearing, where you answer questions under oath about your fall. A court can allow a late notice in some cases, but never plan around that.

1 Year and 90 Days: Lawsuit Against the City

If the claim doesn't settle, you must file suit within one year and 90 days of your fall. The 90-day notice doesn't stop this clock. Both deadlines run from the same date.

3 Years: Lawsuit Against a Private Owner

Claims against private owners, grate owners that aren't public entities, and contractors carry a three-year deadline. The firm's slip and fall statute of limitations guide covers the exceptions. When it's unclear who owns the spot, treat the 90-day deadline as the one that applies.

What to Do Immediately After a Sidewalk Fall in Manhattan

Get medical care first, then document the defect before anyone repairs it.

  1. Get medical treatment right away. Tell the provider exactly where and how you fell so the location appears in your records.
  2. Photograph the defect up close and from a distance. Place a coin, key, or ruler next to it so the photos show its size.
  3. Record the exact location. Note the building address, the nearest cross street, and how far you were from the corner.
  4. Get witness names and phone numbers. Also note any building or store cameras, since many systems overwrite footage within days.
  5. Keep your shoes and clothing. Store them as they were, without cleaning them.
  6. Don't give a recorded statement to the owner's insurer. Their adjuster is gathering evidence against your claim.
  7. Call a lawyer well before day 90. Ownership questions take time to answer, and the Notice of Claim deadline doesn't wait.

What Happens After You Call Michael Gunzburg, P.C.

Your first call starts a free review of your sidewalk fall, and the firm moves quickly to document the scene and lock in your deadlines.

Your Call Is Answered Day or Night

A receptionist answers calls Monday through Friday during business hours. After hours and on weekends, the firm's AI assistant takes your information so the firm can follow up. You never have to wait until Monday to get your claim started.

A Free Consultation About Your Fall

The firm reviews what happened, where you fell, your injuries, and any photos you took. The first question is who is responsible for that spot, because the answer decides whether the 90-day City deadline applies. There's no fee unless the firm recovers money for you.

The Firm Goes to the Scene

The attorney or an investigator working for the firm visits the location in person. They measure and photograph the defect, look for cameras, and check for witnesses before the evidence disappears.

Home or Hospital Visits When You Can't Travel

A serious fall can leave you in a cast, in a wheelchair, or in the hospital. The firm offers home and hospital visits so your claim keeps moving while you recover.

Building Your Claim

The firm pulls ownership records, permit histories, and any written notice the City received. If the City or the MTA is involved, the firm files the Notice of Claim well ahead of the 90-day deadline.

Key Takeaways

  • Under Administrative Code § 7-210, the building owner, not the City, is responsible for most Manhattan sidewalks, while the City keeps curbs, tree wells, and sidewalks outside owner-occupied one- to three-family homes.
  • A fall within 12 inches of a subway grate or utility cover puts responsibility on the hardware owner, such as New York City Transit or Con Edison, under 34 RCNY § 2-07.
  • NYC law treats a height difference of one-half inch or more between sidewalk slabs as a trip hazard the owner must repair, but New York sets no minimum defect size for bringing a claim.
  • A claim against the City requires a Notice of Claim within 90 days and a lawsuit within one year and 90 days, while a claim against a private owner has three years.
  • Michael Gunzburg, P.C. sends the attorney or an investigator to the scene to document the defect before the owner can repair it.

Proven Results and Client Experience

Michael Gunzburg, P.C. has recovered millions for New Yorkers hurt by dangerous property conditions over more than 39 years of New York City trial work.

  • $750,000 trial settlement: A woman tripped and fell in a dangerous hole in a public sidewalk. She suffered an L4-L5 herniated disc that required open-back surgery, including a laminectomy and discectomy.
  • $1.7 million mediated settlement: Jeffrey tripped on an unmarked, protruding step at the entrance of a 200-year-old landmarked building in the West Village. The firm won a ruling that the step violated the New York City Building Code. His case settled after he needed shoulder replacement surgery.
  • $10.1 million settlement: Noel was walking on the sidewalk near 59th Street and Lexington Avenue when ice fell from a building and struck his neck. This was a falling-ice case, not a slip. The firm uncovered evidence that the building owner had known about the ice hazard for years and had agreed in writing to fix it.

In Jeffrey's words, after he hired the firm, Michael Gunzburg "went to the accident site the following morning and began to research the circumstances of my fall." Read more verdicts and settlements or client reviews.

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case.

Common Questions About Sidewalk Slip and Fall Claims in Manhattan

Who is responsible for the sidewalk in front of a Manhattan building?

The owner of the building is responsible for maintaining the sidewalk in front of it under Administrative Code § 7-210, even though the sidewalk is part of the public street. The owner must repair raised slabs, holes, and other defects, and the owner can be sued if a defect injures you. The main exception is a one-, two-, or three-family home that is owner-occupied and used only as a residence. For those homes, the City of New York keeps responsibility. Tree wells and curbs also stay with the City.

Can I sue New York City for a sidewalk fall?

Yes, you can sue New York City when the City is responsible for the spot where you fell, such as a curb, a tree well, City property, or the sidewalk outside an owner-occupied one- to three-family home. You must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days and sue within one year and 90 days. You also need to show the City had written notice of the defect at least 15 days before your fall, unless an exception applies. Maps filed with the City by the Big Apple Pothole and Sidewalk Protection Committee are a common source of that written notice.

How long do I have to file a claim after falling on a NYC sidewalk?

You have 90 days to file a Notice of Claim if the City, the MTA, or another public entity is responsible, and one year and 90 days to file the lawsuit. Claims against a private property owner or contractor carry a three-year deadline under CPLR § 214. Ownership isn't always clear right away, so treat the 90-day deadline as the one that applies until a lawyer confirms otherwise. A late Notice of Claim requires court permission, and courts don't always grant it.

What if the owner says the defect was too small to matter?

A small defect can still support a claim, because New York sets no minimum size for a sidewalk defect. Courts weigh the defect's width, depth, and shape along with the lighting, weather, and crowds when you fell. NYC Administrative Code § 19-152 requires owners to repair height differences of one-half inch or more between slabs, which helps show a defect was a real hazard. Photos with a coin or ruler for scale, taken before any repair, are the strongest response to a trivial defect argument.

Who is responsible if I tripped near a subway grate?

The owner of the grate is responsible for the grate and the 12 inches of sidewalk around it under 34 RCNY § 2-07. For most subway grates in Manhattan, that owner is New York City Transit, part of the MTA, not the building owner. A claim against New York City Transit requires a Notice of Claim within 90 days, the same as a City claim. Measuring how far the defect sat from the grate matters, because a few inches can change who is liable.

Can I still recover if I was looking at my phone when I fell?

Yes. Looking at your phone doesn't bar your claim in New York. Under pure comparative negligence, a jury can assign you a share of the fault and reduce your award by that percentage, but you still recover the rest. Owners raise distraction arguments often, and the evidence frequently cuts the other way. A defect that blended into the pavement, sat in shadow, or was hidden by a crowd is a hazard whether or not you were looking down.

What if the owner repaired the sidewalk after I fell?

A repair after your fall doesn't end your claim. Owners often patch defects quickly because they know a lawsuit may follow. The firm can rebuild what the sidewalk looked like using your photos, witness accounts, City inspection and violation records, permit filings, and dated street-level imagery. The attorney or an investigator for the firm goes to the scene quickly to document what remains. The sooner you call, the more evidence is still there.

How much does a sidewalk slip and fall lawyer cost?

Michael Gunzburg, P.C. handles sidewalk slip and fall cases on a contingency fee, so you pay no attorney's fee unless the firm recovers money for you. The first consultation is free. The fee comes out of the recovery at the end of the case, not out of your pocket while the case is open. That lets you hire an experienced trial lawyer while you're out of work and facing medical bills, without paying anything upfront.

Why hire Michael Gunzburg, P.C. for a sidewalk fall case?

Michael Gunzburg, P.C. brings more than 39 years of New York City trial experience and a working knowledge of the sidewalk, grate, and notice rules that decide these cases. The attorney or an investigator goes to the scene in person, and the firm offers home and hospital visits when you can't travel. Michael Gunzburg is also a Certified Public Accountant, which shapes how the firm calculates lost earnings. The firm's results include a $750,000 trial settlement for a fall in a hole in a public sidewalk.

Areas We Serve

Michael Gunzburg, P.C. represents Manhattan injury victims from its office at 950 Third Avenue in Midtown East. That includes the cobblestone blocks of SoHo and Tribeca, the crowded sidewalks of the Financial District, and the brownstone streets of the West Village and Upper West Side. The firm also serves Chelsea and Hell's Kitchen, Downtown Manhattan, Harlem, and Washington Heights, plus the other four boroughs and Nassau and Suffolk Counties.

Get Started With a Sidewalk Slip and Fall Lawyer in Manhattan

If you fell on a Manhattan sidewalk, the 90-day clock for a City claim may already be running. Call Michael Gunzburg, P.C. at (212) 725-8500 or contact the firm online for a free consultation. A receptionist answers during business hours, and the firm's AI assistant takes your details after hours and on weekends. You pay nothing unless the firm recovers money for you.