NJ Supreme Court tosses claim for punitive damages in malpractice case against Valley
In a closely watched medical malpractice case that attracted a Who’s Who of health care advocates, the New Jersey Supreme Court has sided with The Valley Hospital and its director of minimally invasive gynecologic surgery in a lawsuit about a 43-year-old woman’s death after a surgical device spread cancer in her abdomen.
Valley, Dr. Howard H. Jones and various hospital administrators will not have to face claims for punitive damages, which are highly unusual, in the case filed by family members of Viviana Ruscitto, a Nyack, New York, woman who died in 2015, leaving a 2-year-old son. The lawsuit now is returned to a lower court for a decision about compensatory damages, which are more common.
The case is one of several filed around the country on behalf of women who died after procedures with a power morcellator, a tool that cuts the uterus or fibroid tumors into pieces small enough to be sucked out through a small incision. The device eliminates the need for open surgery, which has a longer recovery time than laparoscopic surgery. But in some cases, it can spread previously undiagnosed cancer cells throughout the abdomen and shorten patients’ lives.
Click here to read the full story.